Business insight

Before You Automate, Fix the Process

Automation applied to a broken process produces broken results faster. A short argument for doing the boring part first.

2 min read
Share

Automation is appealing precisely because it promises to remove work without requiring anyone to change how they think. Point a tool at the tedious task, and the tedium goes away.

It works when the underlying process is sound. When it is not, automation does something worse than failing: it preserves the flaw, accelerates it, and makes it considerably harder to see.

What automation does to a bad process

It removes the humans who were quietly fixing it

Most manual processes work partly because people exercise judgement — noticing the obviously wrong figure, chasing the missing approval. Automate the steps and that correction layer disappears, usually without anyone noticing it was there.

It makes the logic invisible

A manual process can be observed. An automated one becomes a system that people stop interrogating, so its assumptions quietly become facts.

It raises the cost of change

Once a flawed process is encoded, changing it means a change request rather than a conversation.

The boring part, briefly

  1. Write down what actually happens — not what the documentation says.
  2. Ask why each step exists. Expect some answers to be “I don't know” or “a regulation that changed years ago”.
  3. Remove the steps that no longer have a reason.
  4. Settle disagreements about how it should work, before a tool settles them for you.
  5. Then automate what remains.

Step two is where the value is. In our experience it is common to find steps that exist because of a system that was replaced, a person who left, or a one-off incident nobody wants to revisit.

The honest version of the promise

Automation does not save time by itself. Removing unnecessary work saves time; automation then makes the remaining necessary work cheaper. Skipping the first part and expecting the second to compensate is the most common way automation projects disappoint.

Working through something like this?

If any of this is relevant to a decision you are facing, we are happy to talk it through — no obligation either way.